Kalam Cosmological Argument

The Kalam Cosmological Argument: A Case For God

Published On: May 20, 2024

EVERYTHING THAT BEGINS TO EXIST HAS A CAUSE…

Exploring the Cosmic Origins of Existence

What lies beyond the farthest reaches of space and before the birth of time itself? This profound existential question has captivated philosophers and scientists across epochs and cultures. The Kalam cosmological argument beckons us to peer beyond the misty veil of the Big Bang and contemplate the ultimate metaphysical reality: the origin of the entire universe from literally nothing.

In this metaphysical odyssey tracing backward through cosmic history, we encounter signs that may unmistakably point towards a transcendent, supernatural source of all reality—an eternally existent, omnipotent Creator. This ancient argument, first developed by medieval Islamic thinkers, rests on three deceptively simple premises that carry seismic implications.

Arising from medieval Islamic philosophy, this ancient argument offers three powerful, yet simple, premises that have reverberated down the ages like the voice of a wise prophet:

  1. Everything That Begins to Exist Has a Cause
  2. The Universe Began to Exist
  3. Therefore, the Universe Has a Cause

The Causal Principle: Why Things Begin to Exist

Think about it: whenever we come across something new—a towering skyscraper, a roaring car, or a captivating book—our minds instinctively ask, “What caused this to exist?” This simple idea lies at the heart of the Kalam Argument: Whatever starts to exist must have a cause. It’s like the steady beat of logic’s drum guiding us through our reasoning.

The Universe’s Finite Existence: Evidence of a Cosmic Birth

Scientific breakthroughs, like the Big Bang theory, have shown us the universe had a beginning—a moment when time, space, and matter burst into existence from a tiny point. The Kalam echoes this, declaring the universe had a starting point, tracing back to that epic moment when everything began.

The Uncaused First Cause: God as the Ultimate Creator

Imagine a vast tapestry being woven by an unseen master weaver, crafting galaxies, atoms, and even thoughts. The Kalam points us toward a transcendent First Cause—a force that kickstarted this cosmic masterpiece and exists beyond our notions of time and space. According to the Kalam, this First Cause is none other than God—the divine Architect who brought the universe into being.

Addressing Cosmic Skepticism: Christian Responses

Like any big idea, the Kalam Argument has its fair share of nay-sayers. Here are some common criticisms and how Christians typically respond:

The Infinite Regress Objection:

Critics ask, “If everything needs a cause, then what caused God?” This could lead to an endless chain of causes, right?

Christians explain God isn’t like anything else. He’s not caused by anything; He’s eternal, existing forever. He’s the foundation of everything, weaving existence from His own timeless essence.

The Argument from Non-belief: Echoes of the Divine Across Cultures

Sceptics point to the diversity of beliefs and rampant non-belief, and ask: if God truly exists, and His existence is that obvious, why are there all these varied responses? Or why doesn’t everyone recognize God as the universe’s first cause?

The multitude of our views about, and responses to, God doesn’t necessarily prove the non-existence of God. While we may all have an innate awareness of God’s existence, we each respond to this awareness in our own ways. Buried within the multiplicity of religions and philosophies, we consistently find core tenets hinting at something transcendent–a belief in realms beyond the physical, the existence of moral codes, an awareness of human sinfulness, a search for purpose and meaning. Even those professing atheistic worldviews wrestle with life’s biggest metaphysical questions.

The Christian may also remind the sceptic of Blaise Pascal’s suggestion that there’s a God-shaped vacuum in each of us that only the real God can fill, and the pretenders can’t. No pursuit of idols, or wealth, or power, or pleasure can ultimately fill this vacuum. Till we come to Him, we have a nagging sense there is something more to existence, some transcendent meaning and purpose we were created for, but are yet sadly missing.

Conclusion: The Implications of the Kalam Cosmological Argument

From the premises of the Kalam Cosmological Argument, a stunning conclusion emerges: the existence of an eternal, necessary, and immensely powerful First Cause or Creator. This First Cause is beyond the physical and temporal universe, existing independently and uncaused. Such a being is fundamentally different from the dependent, finite world we experience.

The Kalam offers a clear philosophical path to understanding God’s existence and essential attributes. It suggests an unimaginably great, eternal, simple, uncaused, supernatural, and incredibly powerful Source that is radically distinct from our finite cosmos. This conclusion may seem astonishing, but it leads us to the idea of a Supreme Reality—one that supports the entire structure of material existence. This reality is what we fittingly call God.

The Kalam presents a logical and straightforward explanation for the mysteries of the universe’s origin. For those open to exploring these profound questions, the argument offers a strong case for God’s existence, encouraging deeper philosophical and existential reflection. At the very least, the Kalam points us towards the vast, unexplored realms of existence, prompting us to consider the infinite mysteries that lie beyond our physical reality.

Related Reads:

Editor’s Pick
  • Is Jesus Yahweh?
    Is Jesus Yahweh? Answering Unitarian Objections

    The question of whether Jesus Christ is truly God has divided Christians for centuries. While orthodox Christianity has consistently affirmed [...]

  • The Baptism of Fire
    Matthew 3:11: What Is the Baptism of Fire?

    When John the Baptist declared, “He will baptise you with the Holy Spirit and fire” (Matthew 3:11), his words carried [...]

  • Why Jesus called Peter Satan
    From Rock to Stumbling Block: Why Jesus Called Peter Satan

    In the span of just six verses (Matthew 16:13-28), Peter goes from receiving the highest praise from Jesus to getting [...]

  • Struggle With Habitual Sin
    Can Repentance be Real If We Struggle With Habitual Sin?

    We’ve been there before. The weight of conviction sinks in as we realise we’ve fallen into the same sin. All [...]

  • Ketef Hinnom Scrolls
    The Ketef Hinnom Scrolls: An Accidental Yet Phenomenal Find

    SMALLER THAN OUR PALM, OLDER THAN THE DEAD SEA SCROLLS In 1979, a bored 13-year-old volunteer at an archaeological dig [...]

  • Caught in adultery
    Caught in Adultery: How Reliable Is the John 8 Story?

    "Let him who is without sin cast the first stone." Few Bible scenes capture Jesus' wisdom and grace quite like [...]

  • Inscription on Jesus’ Cross
    What Did the Inscription on Jesus’ Cross Really Say?

    A REFORMED RESPONSE TO CLAIMS OF GOSPEL CONTRADICTIONS Sceptics love to point out what they see as a glaring contradiction [...]

  • Rooster Crow at Peter’s Denial
    How Many Times Did the Rooster Crow at Peter’s Denial?

    THE CHALLENGE When sceptics want to undermine Scripture’s reliability, they often point to Peter’s denial as Exhibit A for supposed [...]

  • Biblical and Systematic Theology
    Biblical and Systematic Theology: Why Do We Need Both?

    TWO LENSES, ONE TRUTH Picture this familiar scene: A seminary student sits in the library, torn between two stacks of [...]

  • The Anointed Ones in Zechariah
    The Mysterious Two: Who Are the Anointed Ones in Zechariah?

    Picture this: a golden lampstand blazing with light, flanked by two olive trees that pour oil directly into the lamp’s [...]