Christian Defence of the Moral Argument

Christian Defence of the Moral Argument: Grounding Morality

Published On: May 20, 2024

The Universal Moral Code: The Argument for a Caring, Morally Just God

The moral argument for God’s existence presents a powerful case for a divine source of objective morality. While detractors have raised questions and criticisms, Christian thinkers have provided nuanced responses that deepen our understanding of morality’s divine connection. The existence of a caring, morally just God is, any day, a far better explanation for the universal moral code than the notion it arises from mere matter, time, and chance. This argument not only addresses cultural differences and moral relativism but also tackles evolutionary explanations, presenting a compelling starting point for exploring God’s existence.

Overcoming Cultural Differences and Moral Relativism

Core vs. Peripheral Morality: Critics argue moral values are not universal and vary widely across cultures. However, Christians point out that while there are differences in specific practices (peripheral morality), core moral values—such as the protection of innocent life and the importance of keeping promises—are consistent across cultures. These fundamental moral truths suggest that some ethical principles are universally recognized and serve as a global ethical foundation.

The “Spotlight Effect”: Another criticism is that different cultures focus on different aspects of moral issues, leading to apparent contradictions. Christians respond with the “spotlight effect” analogy: imagine a spotlight illuminating a single moral issue from various angles. While each culture may emphasize different facets of the issue, they are ultimately addressing the same core principle. For example, all cultures value human life, even if they express this value differently.

Divine Revelation and Moral Development: Critics often question how moral values can be universal if they have evolved over time. Christians believe God has progressively revealed objective moral standards throughout history through prophets, scriptures, and spiritual insights. This divine revelation has influenced various cultures, creating a common thread of moral understanding that unites diverse moral expressions.

Addressing Evolutionary Explanations and Moral Evolution

The “Is/Ought” Gap: Evolutionary theory suggests moral behaviours developed because they were advantageous for survival. However, this explanation faces the “is/ought” problem: it explains what is (how moral behaviours came about) but not what ought to be (why we feel a moral obligation to act in certain ways). Christians argue that even if moral behaviours evolved, our deep sense of moral duty suggests a higher grounding beyond mere survival instincts.

The Problem of Evil: Critics argue that if morality is purely a product of evolution aimed at survival, then why do humans universally condemn atrocities like genocide and torture, which don’t directly threaten survival? Christians respond that the existence of objective moral evil—actions universally recognized as wrong—implies a higher moral standard. This standard cannot be fully explained by evolutionary theory and points to a moral framework that transcends human evolution.

The Argument from Morality to Design: Finally, some argue that if morality evolved naturally, it doesn’t require a divine explanation. Christians counter that the complexity and coherence of moral reasoning suggest an intelligent design. Just as the intricate design of a bird’s wing points to a creator, our sophisticated moral compass may reflect intentional design by a higher intelligence.

A Compelling Starting Point for Exploring God’s Existence

The moral argument serves as a powerful philosophical entryway into the exploration of morality’s origins and its implications for our understanding of the divine. The consistent presence of core moral values across cultures and the inherent sense of moral obligation point to a transcendent source. While detractors continue to raise questions, the existence of a caring, morally just God remains a far more satisfying explanation for the universal moral code than the randomness of matter, time, and chance.

Engaging with the moral argument with an open mind allows us to delve deeper into the origins of morality and its implications for our understanding of the divine. It encourages us to consider that our shared moral experiences are not coincidental but indicative of a deeper, purposeful design. This perspective not only enriches our understanding of morality but also opens up new avenues for exploring the profound questions about our existence and the universe’s ultimate purpose.

Related Reads

Editor’s Pick
  • The Book of Enoch
    Shouldn’t the Book of Enoch Be In the Bible? Why Isn’t It?

    The Book of Enoch has fascinated scholars, theologians, and curious readers for centuries. Mentioned in the New Testament and revered [...]

  • Out of Egypt I called my Son
    ‘Out of Egypt I Called My Son’: Did Matthew Misuse Hosea 11:1?

    When Matthew quotes Hosea 11:1 in his Gospel—“Out of Egypt I called my son”—he draws a connection that has puzzled [...]

  • Bible allusions
    Bible Allusions: How They Enrich Our Grasp of God’s Word

    Ever experienced that moment when you're reading Scripture and suddenly recognise an echo of another passage? That spark of recognition [...]

  • Old Testament theophanies
    Old Testament Theophanies: What Purposes Did They Serve?

    Throughout the Old Testament, we encounter remarkable moments when God manifests Himself in visible, often tangible forms to His people. [...]

  • How the Holy Spirit helps
    When Words Fail: How the Holy Spirit Helps Us in Our Prayers

    Ever sat down to pray and found yourself at a complete loss for words? Or perhaps you’ve prayed diligently but [...]

  • Righteous Deeds Like Filthy Rags
    Isaiah 64:6: How Are Our Righteous Deeds Like Filthy Rags?

    “We have all become like one who is unclean, and all our righteous deeds are like a polluted garment.” — [...]

  • The Greatest Yet the Least
    The Greatest Yet the Least: How Is John the Baptist Both?

    In Matthew 11:11, Jesus makes a statement that has puzzled Bible readers: “Truly I tell you, among those born of [...]

  • Psalms of Ascent
    The Pilgrim’s Progress: Journeying Through the Psalms of Ascent

    The Psalms of Ascent (Psalms 120-134) are a remarkable collection of fifteen songs that have guided God's people for millennia. [...]

  • Scripture's exile theme
    Not Home Yet: How Scripture’s Exile Theme Shapes Our Faith

    When we read Scripture carefully, a striking pattern emerges: God’s people are almost always on the move, displaced, or living [...]

  • At Pentecost
    At Pentecost: God Fulfils Covenant and Reverses Babel

    The scene is electrifying. Jerusalem, crowded with Jewish pilgrims from across the known world. A sound like rushing wind fills [...]