Christian Science: Not quite Christian

Christian Science: Key Differences with Bible Doctrine

Published On: June 12, 2024

Christian Science is a religious movement that arose in the late 19th century in New England, founded by Mary Baker Eddy. While including some biblical terminology, Christian Science teachings depart significantly from mainstream, orthodox Christian doctrine as derived from scripture.

Origins and Founder: Mary Baker Eddy (1821-1910) founded Christian Science after claiming to experience a healing from severe injuries in 1866. She attributed the healing to a spiritual insight. In 1875 she published her key work, Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures, outlining her beliefs. The first Christian Science church was established in 1879 in Boston.

Core Teachings and Beliefs

  • View of God: Christian Scientists believe in one, infinite divine Mind or Principle rather than a personal, triune God. God is synonymous with Life, Truth, Love, Spirit, Soul, etc.
  • View of Jesus: Jesus is seen as a spiritual teacher and highest human concept of the divine Mind, but not the unique Son of God. His material death and bodily resurrection are denied.
  • View of Sin and Salvation: Sin, evil and suffering are considered illusions or mistaken beliefs rather than reality. Salvation is attained through denial of material existence and affirmation of spiritual perfection.
  • Rejection of the Material World: Christian Science teaches that the material universe, including the human body, is a mistaken perception by finite minds. Only the spiritual is truly real.
  • View of Scripture: The Bible is viewed as allegorical rather than a historical record. Eddy’s writings in Science and Health are considered inspired and more authoritative than scripture.

Key Differences from Biblical Christianity

  • Denial of the Trinity: Christian Science denies the doctrine of the Trinity—that teaches God is one Being, but exists eternally in three co-equal, co-eternal Persons—the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
  • Rejection of the full deity and bodily incarnation of Jesus: It rejects the full deity and bodily incarnation of Christ, who according to biblical teaching is the eternal Son of God who took on human flesh.
  • Denial of Jesus’ physical, bodily death and resurrection: Christian Science rejects the biblical account that Jesus physically suffered and died on the cross. It claims Jesus did not actually have a physical, material body that could experience death. His physical form is seen more as a mental perception than reality.
  • Rejection of sin as a reality needing atonement through Christ’s sacrifice. Eddy rejected the biblical teaching that sin is a reality in dire need of atonement and faith in the sacrificial death of Jesus Christ on the cross is the only means of atonement.
  • View of the material world, including our bodies, as unreal illusions. The material world, including our physical human bodies, is an unreal illusion, Eddy taught, rather than an actual creation of God.
  • Eddy’s writings supersede the Bible: Ultimately, the writings of Mary Baker Eddy in Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures take precedence over the Bible as the authoritative truth, contrary to the Protestant Christian view of the Bible as God’s infallible, inerrant Word.

While using some biblical terminology, key Christian Science teachings effectively deny core doctrines of historical Christianity derived from scripture – the nature of God, the person and work of Jesus Christ, the reality of sin, and the truth of Jesus’ bodily resurrection. These fundamental differences place Christian Science outside the boundaries of biblical, orthodox Christianity despite some shared terminology.

An evaluation of Christian Science’s key beliefs reveals these do not align with the historic biblical gospel as understood by believers through the centuries. While well-intentioned, Christian Science represents a modernist departure from the central tenets of the historic Christian faith.

Related Reads

Editor’s Pick
  • The Holy Spirit’s indwelling
    The Holy Spirit’s Indwelling: How Can I Be Sure I Have It?

    “Am I truly saved? How can I know for certain that the Holy Spirit lives within me?” If you’ve wrestled [...]

  • Did Mary Remain a Virgin?
    Did Mary Remain a Virgin? A Biblical Case Against Perpetual Virginity

    The question of Mary’s perpetual virginity has divided Christians for centuries. While Catholic and Orthodox traditions affirm Mary remained a [...]

  • Occam’s Razor
    Is Occam’s Razor a Compelling Argument Against Theism?

    WHY THE ARGUMENT ACTUALLY POINTS TO GOD   Picture this: You're in a coffee shop debate with a confident sceptic [...]

  • Justification in the Old Testament
    Is the Doctrine of Justification in the Old Testament?

    WAS PAUL INVENTING SOMETHING NEW OR REVEALING SOMETHING ANCIENT? Picture this scene: You’re discussing faith with a thoughtful sceptic who [...]

  • General and Special Revelation
    How God Reveals Himself to Us: General and Special Revelation

    Every human heart carries an undeniable longing to know ultimate truth—to understand our place in the universe and the longing [...]

  • Doctrine of God and Bible Interpretation
    Doctrine of God and Bible Interpretation: Are The Two Connected?

    Picture this: Two seasoned pastors read the same verse about God's sovereignty and human responsibility. One concludes God determines all [...]

  • Not Peace But a Sword
    What Did Jesus Mean: ‘I Bring Not Peace But a Sword’?

    Jesus’ statement may sound perplexing to us at first read: "Do not think that I have come to bring peace [...]

  • Nine Marks of Those Jesus Calls Blessed
    The Beatitudes: The Nine Marks of Those Jesus Calls Blessed

    When Jesus climbed that hillside in Galilee and began to speak, He turned the world's understanding of blessing upside down. [...]

  • Why Jesus Calls Mourning a Blessing
    Sacred Sorrow: Why Jesus Calls Mourning a Blessing

    MAKING SENSE OF THE DIVINE PARADOX IN MATTHEW 5:4 When Jesus declared, “Blessed are those who mourn, for they will [...]

  • ‘Sell Everything You Have'
    ‘Sell Everything You Have…’: Are We To Do So Literally?

    When Jesus encountered the rich young ruler in Matthew 19:21, His words cut through with startling clarity: “If you want [...]