The Doctrine of Providence: Does God Really Govern All Things?

Published On: November 24, 2025

You’re sitting in the doctor’s office when the diagnosis lands like a thunderclap. Your mind races: Why this? Why now? Why me? Or perhaps it’s the opposite—an unexpected promotion, a recovered relationship, a narrow escape from disaster. Your heart swells with gratitude, but to whom? To luck? To fate? To the universe?

What if there’s no such thing as chance? What if every sparrow’s fall, every hair numbered, every moment—joyful or agonising—is woven into a tapestry of purpose by the hand of a sovereign Father? This is the Reformed doctrine of providence, and it changes everything about how we suffer, hope, and worship.

WHAT IS PROVIDENCE? THE CLASSICAL DEFINITION

The Heidelberg Catechism, one of the Reformation’s great teaching documents, asks in Question 27: “What do you understand by the providence of God?” The answer is breathtaking: “The almighty and everywhere present power of God; whereby, as it were by his hand, he upholds and governs heaven, earth, and all creatures; so that herbs and grass, rain and drought, fruitful and barren years, meat and drink, health and sickness, riches and poverty, yea, and all things come, not by chance, but by his fatherly hand.”

Read that again slowly. All things. Not some things. Not just the big, dramatic things. Herbs and grass. Your bank account. Your diagnosis. Your mundane Tuesday afternoon. Nothing—absolutely nothing—happens by chance, but by His fatherly hand.

The Westminster Confession of Faith goes a step further, addressing the hardest question: What about evil? What about sin? Chapter 5, section 1 declares God’s providence extends even to “the first fall, and all other sins of angels and men,” not by “bare permission” (as if God were caught off-guard), “but such as hath joined with it a most wise and powerful bounding, and otherwise ordering and governing of them.”

Here’s the crucial distinction: Providence isn’t deism—the idea that God wound up the universe like a clock and walked away. Nor is it fatalism—the cold machinery of impersonal fate grinding forward. Providence is the personal, purposeful, exhaustive governance of a Father who “works all things according to the counsel of his will” (Ephesians 1:11). He doesn’t merely react to history; He authors it. Every minute detail of it.

HOW PROVIDENCE WORKS: THE THREEFOLD DISTINCTION

Theologians have traditionally distinguished three aspects of God’s providential work. These aren’t three separate activities but three angles on one comprehensive reality.

Preservation means God actively sustains all creation moment by moment. Hebrews 1:3 tells us Christ “upholds the universe by the word of his power.” Colossians 1:17 adds that “in him all things hold together.” This isn’t passive maintenance, like a table holding a vase. It’s dynamic, continuous creation. God doesn’t wind up your heart and let it tick; He wills every beat. If He withdrew His sustaining word for one nanosecond, the cosmos—and you—would collapse into nothingness. Every atom’s spin, every breath you take exists only because He actively wills it right now.
Concurrence means God doesn’t merely preserve creation from the outside—He cooperates with secondary causes. Paul told the Athenians, “In him we live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28). When we choose, when we act, when we work, we’re not acting independently of God’s power—yet we’re acting genuinely as responsible agents. Psalm 104 illustrates this beautifully: “When you send forth your Spirit, they are created” (v.30). God’s action and creaturely action aren’t competing; they’re concurrent. This is mystery, not contradiction. God’s sovereignty and human responsibility are both fully real, both fully operative.
Government means God doesn’t just sustain and cooperate—He directs all things toward His predetermined ends. “The LORD has established his throne in the heavens, and his kingdom rules over all” (Psalm 103:19). The pagan king Nebuchadnezzar learned this the hard way: God “does according to his will among the host of heaven and among the inhabitants of the earth; and none can stay his hand” (Daniel 4:35). No rogue molecule. No maverick dictator. No cancer cell operates outside His decree. This includes suffering. This includes evil—which God ordains without being its author, permits without being passive, and judges without being unjust. Every thread in history’s tapestry, dark or bright, is woven by His hand.

WHY THIS MATTERS: PASTORAL COMFORT AND PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

Providence turns victims into pilgrims. When suffering strikes, our default is to see ourselves as victims of random chaos. But Romans 8:28 demolishes randomness: “We know that for those who love God all things work together for good.” Not some things. All things. The same chapter climaxes with the great battle cry: nothing—“neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come…nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (vv.35–39). Our hardest trial isn’t chaos interrupting God’s plan; it is the plan. Joseph told his treacherous brothers, “You meant evil against me, but God meant it for good” (Genesis 50:20). Same event. Two meanings. One ultimate purpose.

Providence frees us from anxiety. Jesus commands, “Do not be anxious about your life” (Matthew 6:25), not because worry is impolite but because it’s irrational under God’s government. Your Father feeds sparrows and clothes lilies—and you’re worth infinitely more. If God numbers the hairs on your head and ordains the number of your days, anxiety can’t add a single hour to your life. But trusting His providence can fill every hour with peace.

Providence fuels humility and worship. Every breath, every trial, every joy flows from the Father’s hand (James 1:17). We didn’t earn our next heartbeat. That success we’re proud of? “What do you have that you did not receive?” (1 Corinthians 4:7). That suffering we resent? Job asked his wife, “Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?” (Job 2:10). Providence crushes pride and ignites gratitude. It turns every moment into worship.

Providence drives mission. If God governs history—raising kingdoms, scattering nations, orchestrating encounters—then missions aren’t uncertain. The Great Commission rests on Christ’s claim: “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me” (Matthew 28:18). Our witness, our prayers, our obedience aren’t shots in the dark. They’re God’s ordained means to His certain ends.

LIVING UNDER THE HAND

Nothing happens by chance. Not your reading this sentence. Not tomorrow’s trials. Not the ultimate triumph of Christ’s kingdom. The same Hand that flung stars into space holds us—and He is our Father. Let’s learn to rest in that today.

RELATED FAQs

If Scripture is right about God’s providence, does it mean there is no such thing as luck or chance? Correct—there is no such thing as luck, chance, or randomness in ultimate reality. What we call “chance” is simply our ignorance of God’s hidden purposes. When you flip a coin, the outcome feels random to you because you can’t calculate all the physical forces at play, but God ordained that result before the foundation of the world. As RC Sproul famously put it, “There are no maverick molecules” running around the universe outside God’s control. What appears contingent to us is certain to Him.

Why do we have terms such as luck, good fortune, and chance in our languages, then? These terms describe our experience and perspective, not ultimate reality. From our finite, earthbound viewpoint, events often appear random or unexpected—we genuinely don’t know what will happen next. The Bible itself uses this language accommodatively: Ecclesiastes speaks of “time and chance” happening to all (9:11), and the soldiers casting lots for Jesus’ garments thought they were gambling (John 19:24). But Scripture simultaneously reveals God was sovereignly orchestrating even that “random” act to fulfil prophecy (Psalm 22:18). Language of chance describes the creaturely level of causation; providence describes the divine level—and the divine governs the creaturely.
How are believers to view random, unexplained, even freak incidents that happen? Scripture trains us to view “freak accidents” and unexplained incidents as mysterious but meaningful appointments from God’s hand. Modern Reformed theologian John Frame writes “chance events are divine appointments in disguise.” That flat tire that made you miss your flight, that chance encounter at the coffee shop, that sudden illness—these aren’t cosmic glitches but purposeful (though, to us, often inscrutable) elements of our Father’s wise plan. We may never understand why in this life, but we trust who: the God who works all things for the good of those who love Him (Romans 8:28).

Does providence mean God causes sin? How do Reformed theologians handle this tension? Reformed theology insists that God ordains whatsoever comes to pass, including sinful acts, yet He is never the author or approver of sin. John Piper explains this using “asymmetry”: God relates differently to good and evil—He directly causes good, but He permits, restrains, and uses evil for good purposes without being morally responsible for it. Westminster Confession 5.4 states “the sinfulness thereof proceedeth only from the creature, and not from God.” Think of Joseph’s story: his brothers sinned freely and culpably, yet God ordained their evil deed to save nations (Genesis 50:20). It’s mystery, not contradiction—divine sovereignty and human responsibility run on parallel tracks that meet in God’s mind, not ours.

What about prayer and human effort—do they matter if God has already decided everything? Absolutely yes—prayer and effort are themselves part of God’s decreed means to His ordained ends. Michael Horton explains that God doesn’t just decree the what (outcomes) but also the how (means). God has ordained we’ll eat dinner tonight, but that doesn’t mean we stop grocery shopping—shopping is the means He’s ordained! Similarly, God ordains both that certain things will happen and that they’ll happen through your prayers and efforts. James 5:16 says “the prayer of a righteous person has great power”—not despite God’s sovereignty, but because of it. Our prayers aren’t trying to change God’s mind; they’re participating in the way He’s chosen to accomplish His will.
How does the doctrine of providence relate to modern science and natural laws? Providence doesn’t contradict science; it grounds it. Reformed epistemologist Alvin Plantinga notes natural laws describe God’s regular, predictable ways of governing creation—they’re descriptions of His normal providence, not autonomous forces. When scientists discover cause-and-effect relationships, they’re thinking God’s thoughts after Him, tracing the patterns of His concurrence with secondary causes. Modern Reformed scholars like Vern Poythress argue that scientific laws (gravity, thermodynamics, etc.) are simply our way of describing how God faithfully and consistently upholds the universe moment by moment (Hebrews 1:3). Miracles aren’t violations of natural law but special instances where God acts unusually within His own creation—like an author stepping into his novel.

If everything is providentially ordained, how can I be genuinely grateful for gifts from other people? You should be doubly grateful—thankful both to the human giver and to God who moved their heart and orchestrated the circumstances! As Tim Keller pointed out, providence doesn’t eliminate secondary causes or creaturely agency; it establishes and dignifies them. When someone shows us kindness, they’re acting freely and deserve genuine thanks—but God is simultaneously working through them as His instrument of grace. James 1:17 says “every good gift…is from above, coming down from the Father,” yet we still thank the friend who brought the meal, the spouse who encouraged us, the stranger who helped us. Providence doesn’t flatten human relationships into divine puppetry; it enriches them by revealing that behind every act of love stands the ultimate Lover.

OUR RELATED POSTS