Why does God show grace to some sinners, and send others to hell?

Why Does God Show Grace to Some Sinners and Send Others to Hell?

Published On: May 31, 2024

Sure we know God is just and holy. We know, too, all of humanity has sinned and fallen short of God’s glorious standard. Given these truths, a perplexing question we can ponder over is this: Why does God show grace to some sinners and send others to hell? Shouldn’t He either punish every sinner or extend grace to all? Anything else appears either capricious or unfair. And yet, the Bible is clear some will inherit eternal life while others face everlasting hell.

Why does God show grace to some sinners and send others to hell?

The dilemma strikes at the very heart of how we understand God’s character and dealings with humanity. As we wrestle with this difficult question, here are some key considerations for us to mull over:

  1. NO ONE RECEIVES INJUSTICE FROM GOD: After all, every one of us has sinned and deserves hell. Scripture is clear all have sinned and fallen short of God’s glory (Romans 3:23). The wages of sin is death (Romans 6:23), and the righteous judgment of God is to condemn sinners to eternal separation from Him in hell (Revelation 20:11-15). In this sense, if God were to send all of us to hell, He would be acting justly, as we have all earned that punishment through our rebellion against our holy Creator.

  2. NONE OF US MERITS GRACE: Grace, by definition, is unmerited favour. In other words, if we merited it, it would not be grace. The late RC Sproul states it eloquently: “Grace, by definition, is something God is not required to grant. He owes a fallen world no mercy. If we cried out for justice at His hands, we could all receive the just condemnation we deserve. Justice is what we deserve. Grace is always and ever undeserved. If we deserved it, it would not be grace.”

  3. SOME OF US DO RECEIVE GRACE: While all humanity stands condemned before a holy God, the amazing truth of the gospel is that God, in His infinite love and mercy, has chosen to extend the gift of salvation to some (Ephesians 2:8-9). This grace is not earned or deserved but is a free gift made possible through faith in the sacrificial death of Jesus Christ on the cross (Romans 5:8).

  4. GOD CAN BE JUST AND STILL NOT SHOW GRACE TO EVERYONE: As Sproul highlighted, there is no injustice in God granting mercy to some while allowing others to receive the just consequences of their sin. If God chooses to pardon one guilty person, it does not make those He does not pardon any less guilty or deserving of condemnation. God is not obligated to extend grace to all; rather, the wonder is He extends grace to anyone at all.

So, why does God show grace to some sinners and send others to hell? Paul directly anticipates this question in Romans 9:14-15, asking “What shall we say then? There is no injustice with God, is there? May it never be! For He says to Moses, ‘I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.'” Paul is making it clear there is no injustice with God in showing mercy to some and not others, because no one deserves or has a claim on God’s grace and compassion in the first place. God is completely just in extending undeserved grace to some while allowing others to receive their justly deserved condemnation.

The beauty of grace is it is freely given—not to those who are owed it, but to those who are not. In extending grace to some, God’s justice toward others is in no way diminished. May we never lose sight of the profound reality we all deserve condemnation. And any salvation we receive is an undeserved gift from a loving and merciful God.

Related Reads:

 

Editor’s Pick
  • Is the Holy Spirit Present in Unbelievers?
    Is the Holy Spirit Present in Unbelievers? The Biblical Answer

    Can someone who doesn’t believe in Jesus Christ have the Holy Spirit living inside them? This question strikes at the [...]

  • The Gap Theory Exposed
    The Gap Theory Exposed: Why Embrace a Young Earth?

    The Gap Theory proposes there’s a vast time gap—millions or billions of years—between Genesis 1:1 (“In the beginning God created [...]

  • Sickle cell anaemia
    Rethinking Sickle Cell Anaemia: A Case for Intelligent Design

    Sickle cell anaemia presents what many consider evolution’s strongest card—a genetic condition that causes suffering yet provides protection against malaria. [...]

  • ‘Bad’ Design in Nature
    ‘Bad’ Design: Flaw in Nature Or Flaw in Our Perspective?

    When the Eiffel Tower was first proposed, critics called it a monstrous eyesore that would ruin Paris forever. Today, it’s [...]

  • The Problem of Divine Absence
    The Problem of Divine Absence: How Do Believers Cope?

    WHEN GOD SEEMS FAR: THE GREAT DISCONNECT Ever wondered why God seemed so close to Joseph in his Egyptian prison, [...]

  • Is ‘Gay Christian’ A Biblically Acceptable Identity?
    Is ‘Gay Christian’ a Biblically Acceptable Identity to Have?

    THE QUESTION OF IDENTITY IN BIBLICAL PERSPECTIVE The term “gay Christian” has become increasingly common in contemporary religious discourse, representing [...]

  • What does 'born of water' mean?
    What Does ‘Born of Water’ in John 3:5 Mean?

    THE REFORMED VIEW VS OTHER INTERPRETATIONS ”Jesus answered, ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water [...]

  • Lordship Salvation
    The Lordship Salvation Controversy: What’s It All About?

    Can someone be truly saved without making Jesus Christ their Lord? The question sits at the heart of one of [...]

  • Water and Blood
    1 John 5:6: How Do Water and Blood Reveal Jesus’ True Identity?

    "This is he who came by water and blood—Jesus Christ; not by the water only but by the water and [...]

  • Is Jesus Yahweh?
    Is Jesus Yahweh? Answering Unitarian Objections

    The question of whether Jesus Christ is truly God has divided Christians for centuries. While orthodox Christianity has consistently affirmed [...]