Why Does God Show Grace to Some Sinners and Send Others to Hell?
Sure we know God is just and holy. We know, too, all of humanity has sinned and fallen short of God’s glorious standard. Given these truths, a perplexing question we can ponder over is this: Why does God show grace to some sinners and send others to hell? Shouldn’t He either punish every sinner or extend grace to all? Anything else appears either capricious or unfair. And yet, the Bible is clear some will inherit eternal life while others face everlasting hell.
Why does God show grace to some sinners and send others to hell?
The dilemma strikes at the very heart of how we understand God’s character and dealings with humanity. As we wrestle with this difficult question, here are some key considerations for us to mull over:
-
NO ONE RECEIVES INJUSTICE FROM GOD: After all, every one of us has sinned and deserves hell. Scripture is clear all have sinned and fallen short of God’s glory (Romans 3:23). The wages of sin is death (Romans 6:23), and the righteous judgment of God is to condemn sinners to eternal separation from Him in hell (Revelation 20:11-15). In this sense, if God were to send all of us to hell, He would be acting justly, as we have all earned that punishment through our rebellion against our holy Creator.
-
NONE OF US MERITS GRACE: Grace, by definition, is unmerited favour. In other words, if we merited it, it would not be grace. The late RC Sproul states it eloquently: “Grace, by definition, is something God is not required to grant. He owes a fallen world no mercy. If we cried out for justice at His hands, we could all receive the just condemnation we deserve. Justice is what we deserve. Grace is always and ever undeserved. If we deserved it, it would not be grace.”
-
SOME OF US DO RECEIVE GRACE: While all humanity stands condemned before a holy God, the amazing truth of the gospel is that God, in His infinite love and mercy, has chosen to extend the gift of salvation to some (Ephesians 2:8-9). This grace is not earned or deserved but is a free gift made possible through faith in the sacrificial death of Jesus Christ on the cross (Romans 5:8).
-
GOD CAN BE JUST AND STILL NOT SHOW GRACE TO EVERYONE: As Sproul highlighted, there is no injustice in God granting mercy to some while allowing others to receive the just consequences of their sin. If God chooses to pardon one guilty person, it does not make those He does not pardon any less guilty or deserving of condemnation. God is not obligated to extend grace to all; rather, the wonder is He extends grace to anyone at all.
So, why does God show grace to some sinners and send others to hell? Paul directly anticipates this question in Romans 9:14-15, asking “What shall we say then? There is no injustice with God, is there? May it never be! For He says to Moses, ‘I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.'” Paul is making it clear there is no injustice with God in showing mercy to some and not others, because no one deserves or has a claim on God’s grace and compassion in the first place. God is completely just in extending undeserved grace to some while allowing others to receive their justly deserved condemnation.
The beauty of grace is it is freely given—not to those who are owed it, but to those who are not. In extending grace to some, God’s justice toward others is in no way diminished. May we never lose sight of the profound reality we all deserve condemnation. And any salvation we receive is an undeserved gift from a loving and merciful God.
Related Reads:
Editor’s Pick
A Royal Priesthood: Why Does Peter Address Believers Thus?
The Apostle Peter’s words in 1 Peter 2:9 are striking: they include one of the most profound declarations of Christian [...]
Job’s Many Trials: What Purposes Did They Serve in the End?
The Book of Job is one of Scripture’s most profound explorations of human suffering and divine purpose. Through the devastating [...]
Geologic Dating: Is It a Showstopper for Young Earth Science?
Are Millions of Years Written in Stone? When you pick up a rock, you're holding a piece of Earth's history [...]
Human Immunology: Evidence of Design in Our Defence Systems
The human immune system is one of the most remarkable examples of biological complexity in nature. As our understanding of [...]
The Logos: Why Does John Call Jesus the Word?
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" (John 1:1). The [...]
Hosea & Gomer: Why God Commands a Prophet to Marry a Prostitute
WHEN A MARRIAGE BECOMES A SERMON: ON GOD’S RADICAL LOVE… The command is jarring, even offensive to our modern sensibilities: [...]
Colossians 1:15: How is Jesus the Firstborn of All Creation?
The title “Firstborn of All Creation” is one of Scripture’s most emphatic descriptions of Christ’s pre-eminence, and yet, is often [...]
All of Creation is Groaning: What Does Scripture Mean?
The Apostle Paul presents a remarkable insight in Romans 8:19-22, declaring "the whole creation has been groaning as in the [...]
Freemasonry’s Dark Secrets: A Biblical Analysis
The relationship between Freemasonry and Christianity represents more than just theological controversy—it raises profound spiritual concerns that demand careful examination. [...]
Why Did God Harden Pharaoh’s Heart? The Reformed View
Why did God harden Pharaoh’s heart? Few passages in Scripture present a greater theological challenge than the account of God [...]
